Is Pet Honesty good for dogs?
Yes. Pet Honesty carries the NASC Quality Seal, and its probiotic chews give a 50 lb dog 6 billion CFU a day for $0.59, the third-cheapest NASC-seal probiotic we compared at that dose. Its best buys are the probiotic, the Allergy Support Chews (400 mg turmeric root (Curcuma zedoaria) a day) and the Hemp Hip + Joint Senior Chews (300 mg MSM a day). For the same 6 billion CFU for less, the Native Pet powder costs $0.50 a day.
Best Pet Honesty product
Pet Honesty Probiotics, Gut + Immune Health Soft Chews with Digestive Enzymes, Pumpkin, 180 ct
6 billion CFU a day2 chews a day$0.59 a day1
Best Pet Honesty for itchy dogs
Pet Honesty Allergy Support Soft Chews (Salmon)
400 mg turmeric root (Curcuma zedoaria) a day2 chews a day$0.73 a day2
Best Pet Honesty for older joints
Pet Honesty Hemp Hip + Joint Health Senior Soft Chews (Chicken)
400 mg green-lipped mussel300 mg MSM a day2 chews a day$0.96 a day3
Best value alternative
Native Pet Probiotic Powder (60 scoops)
6 billion CFU a day1 scoop a day$0.50 a day4
We pick the Pet Honesty products whose labels print real amounts, and the lowest-cost NASC-seal probiotic with the same CFU. Cost a day for a 50 lb dog, Amazon prices October 28, 2026.5, 6
Pet Honesty at a glance
For a 50 lb dog, from Pet Honesty labels
Cost per day = the label dose for a 50 lb dog at the Amazon price, October 28, 2026. Median is other brands in the same category.
Which Pet Honesty product fits which job
- Loose stools or a sensitive stomach: Probiotic Chews ($0.59 a day). 6 billion CFU a day. A 25 lb dog gets 3 billion CFU for $0.29. See the best probiotics for dogs.
- Seasonal itch and allergies: Allergy Support Chews ($0.73 a day). 400 mg turmeric root (Curcuma zedoaria), 58 mg omega-3 and 1 billion CFU a day. See the best allergy chews for dogs.
- Stiff joints in older dogs: Hemp Hip + Joint Senior Chews ($0.96 a day). 400 mg green-lipped mussel and 300 mg MSM a day. See the best joint supplements for dogs.
- Stress and noise: Hemp Calming Max Chews ($0.96 a day). Hemp chews with melatonin, ginkgo and lemon balm, 2 chews a day. See the best calming chews.
- Teeth and breath: Teeth Cleaning Powder (Buy on Amazon). A powder you sprinkle on food, 2 scoops a day. See the best dental chews for dogs.
Every Pet Honesty product we compared, by the numbers
5 Pet Honesty products the brand sells on Amazon, best-selling first.
Per day = what the label says to give a dog of that weight, times the amount in each serving. Cost per day = that many servings at the Amazon price, read October 28, 2026.
| Product | For | What a 50 lb dog gets a day | Servings a day | Cost per day |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Pet Honesty Teeth Cleaning Powder | Teeth and breath | — | 2 scoops | Buy on Amazon |
| Pet Honesty Allergy Support Chews | Allergy | 400 mg turmeric + 58 mg omega-3 + 1 billion CFU | 2 chews | $0.73 a day |
| Pet Honesty Probiotic Chews | Gut health | 6 billion CFU probiotics | 2 chews | $0.59 a day |
| Pet Honesty Hemp Hip + Joint Senior Chews | Joints (senior) | 400 mg green-lipped mussel + 300 mg MSM | 2 chews | $0.96 a day |
| Pet Honesty Hemp Calming Max Chews | Calming | Melatonin, ginkgo and lemon balm | 2 chews | $0.96 a day |
Source: Pet Honesty labels; Amazon prices read October 28, 20265
Pet Honesty vs the best alternative, job by job
For each job we show the lowest-cost NASC-seal product that prints the same kind of amounts. Native Pet's probiotic powder gives the same 6 billion CFU for $0.50 against $0.59, and costs less per billion CFU at every weight below.1, 4 Pet Honesty costs less a day at 25 lb ($0.29 against $0.50) and 75 lb ($0.88 against $1.00), because it doses 1 chew per 25 lb and the powder doses 1 scoop up to 50 lb and 2 above.
Against Zesty Paws, Pet Honesty gives the same 6 billion CFU for $0.59 against $0.73, and the allergy chews cost the same, $0.73 a day: Pet Honesty gives 400 mg turmeric root (Curcuma zedoaria), Zesty Paws gives 200 mg colostrum.2, 7 See Zesty Paws vs Pet Honesty.
Alternative = the lowest cost a day among other NASC-seal products in the same job that print the amounts shown. Prices on Amazon, October 28, 2026.
| Job | Pet Honesty | Best alternative with the NASC seal |
|---|---|---|
| Probiotic | Pet Honesty Probiotics, Gut + Immune Health Soft Chews with Digestive Enzymes, Pumpkin, 180 ct 6 billion CFU · $0.59 a day | Native Pet Probiotic Powder (60 scoops) 6 billion CFU · $0.50 a day |
| Allergy | Pet Honesty Allergy Support Soft Chews (Salmon) 400 mg turmeric root (Curcuma zedoaria), 1 billion CFU · $0.73 a day | Pet Naturals Allergy Plus Calming Soft Chews 5 mg colostrum, 100 million CFU · $0.20 a day |
| Joints | Pet Honesty Hemp Hip + Joint Health Senior Soft Chews (Chicken) 400 mg green-lipped mussel, 300 mg MSM · $0.96 a day | PetNC Natural Care Hip & Joint Soft Chews (Liver Flavor) 500 mg glucosamine, 50 mg MSM · $0.19 a day |
| Calming | Pet Honesty Hemp Calming Max Strength Soft Chews (duck) melatonin, ginkgo, lemon balm · $0.96 a day | Native Pet Calm Air-Dried Chews, 30 ct 10 mg melatonin, 100 mg L-theanine · $1.00 a day |
Probiotic by weight: Pet Honesty vs Native Pet
Each label's own dose. Prices on Amazon, October 28, 2026.
| Dog's weight | Pet Honesty | Native Pet |
|---|---|---|
| 25 lb | 1 chew · 3 billion CFU · $0.29 a day | 1 scoop · 6 billion CFU · $0.50 a day |
| 50 lb | 2 chews · 6 billion CFU · $0.59 a day | 1 scoop · 6 billion CFU · $0.50 a day |
| 75 lb | 3 chews · 9 billion CFU · $0.88 a day | 2 scoops · 12 billion CFU · $1.00 a day |
| 100 lb | 4 chews · 12 billion CFU · $1.18 a day | 2 scoops · 12 billion CFU · $1.00 a day |
Allergy chews by weight
Dose by weight from the 1800PetMeds dosing chart. Prices on Amazon, October 28, 2026.
| Dog's weight | Pet Honesty allergy chews |
|---|---|
| 25 lb | 1 chew · 200 mg turmeric root (Curcuma zedoaria) · $0.37 a day |
| 50 lb | 2 chews · 400 mg turmeric root (Curcuma zedoaria) · $0.73 a day |
| 75 lb | 3 chews · 600 mg turmeric root (Curcuma zedoaria) · $1.10 a day |
| 100 lb | 4 chews · 800 mg turmeric root (Curcuma zedoaria) · $1.47 a day |
Source: Pet Honesty and Native Pet labels; Amazon prices read October 28, 20265
The NASC seal, and who owns Pet Honesty
Pet Honesty is on the NASC member list with permission to show the Quality Seal on its supplements.6 To show the seal, a company passes an independent audit, keeps written quality-control procedures and an adverse event reporting system, and submits to random product tests by an independent lab against its label claims.8
Pet Honesty began in Austin, Texas, as an online business, founded by Ben and Camille Arneberg. Vestar Capital Partners, a New York private equity firm, made a majority investment in 2022, and the brand says its supplements are made in the United States.9
Questions people ask
- Is Pet Honesty a good brand?
- Yes. It has the NASC Quality Seal, and its probiotic gives a 50 lb dog 6 billion CFU a day for $0.59, more than 23 of the 34 other probiotics we compared.
- Is Pet Honesty probiotics good for dogs?
- Yes: 6 billion CFU a day for a 50 lb dog at $0.59. A 25 lb dog gets 3 billion CFU for $0.29. The Native Pet powder gives 6 billion CFU for $0.50.
- Is Pet Honesty a good company?
- Pet Honesty is a supplement maker based in Austin, Texas, and a member of the National Animal Supplement Council with permission to show the Quality Seal. Vestar Capital Partners made a majority investment in 2022.
- Is Pet Honesty better than Zesty Paws?
- For probiotics, Pet Honesty gives the same 6 billion CFU a day for less ($0.59 vs $0.73). The allergy chews cost the same, $0.73 a day. Both brands hold the NASC seal.
- Which Pet Honesty is best for itching?
- The Allergy Support Chews: 400 mg turmeric root (Curcuma zedoaria), 58 mg omega-3 and 1 billion CFU a day for $0.73 for a 50 lb dog.
- How much Pet Honesty should I give my dog?
- The chews are dosed 1 chew a day for every 25 lb of body weight, so a 50 lb dog gets 2 and a 100 lb dog gets 4. The allergy chews follow the same steps.
Notes and sources
- Amounts per day and chews per day come from each brand's label, read October 2026. See how we do the math.
- Product photos come from Amazon.
- Prices checked on Amazon October 28, 2026. Published .
Sources
- Pet Honesty label: Probiotics, Gut + Immune Health Soft Chews with Digestive Enzymes, Pumpkin, 180 ct, read October 2026.
- 1800PetMeds: Allergy Support Soft Chews (Salmon), read October 2026.
- Pet Honesty label: Hemp Hip + Joint Health Senior Soft Chews (Chicken), read October 2026.
- Native Pet label: Probiotic Powder (60 scoops), read October 2026.
- Prices: Amazon product data, read October 28, 2026. Cost per serving = listing price divided by the servings in the container.
- National Animal Supplement Council, member list (a green check = permission to show the NASC Quality Seal), read October 28, 2026.
- Zesty Paws label: Daily Probiotic Bites, read October 2026.
- National Animal Supplement Council, "NASC Quality Seal" (independent audit, written quality-control procedures, an adverse event reporting system, and random product testing by an independent lab to ensure products meet label claim), read October 28, 2026.
- Vestar Capital Partners, "Braced for growth: How Austin startup Pet Honesty has become a national brand" (reprint of the Austin American-Statesman article, September 2022), read October 28, 2026.
Labels for the products in the tables
- Native Pet: Calm Air-Dried Chews, 30 ct, Probiotic Powder (60 scoops).
- Pet Honesty: Hemp Calming Max Strength Soft Chews (duck), Hemp Hip + Joint Health Senior Soft Chews (Chicken), Probiotics, Gut + Immune Health Soft Chews with Digestive Enzymes, Pumpkin, 180 ct, Vet Approved Dog Teeth Cleaning Powder, 30 Servings.
- Pet Naturals: Allergy Plus Calming Soft Chews.
- PetNC Natural Care: Hip & Joint Soft Chews (Liver Flavor).
- Zesty Paws: Allergy & Immune Bites (Lamb), Daily Probiotic Bites.