Zesty Paws vs Pet Honesty: which should you buy?

Which to buy, job by job

• Probiotic: Pet Honesty. Both labels give a 50 lb dog 6 billion CFU a day. Pet Honesty costs $0.59 and Zesty Paws $0.73. Pet Honesty says 1 chew per 25 lb, so a 75 lb dog gets 9 billion CFU from it and 6 billion from Zesty Paws, which stays at 2 chews. That makes Zesty Paws cheaper at 75 lb ($0.73 vs $0.88 a day), for fewer CFU.^{1, 6}
• Allergy and itch: Pet Honesty, by a little. Both cost $0.73 a day. Pet Honesty gives 1 billion CFU and 400 mg turmeric root (Curcuma zedoaria); Zesty Paws gives 200 mg colostrum and 500 million CFU. Pick Zesty Paws if you want colostrum, Pet Honesty if you want more CFU or turmeric root. At 75 lb Pet Honesty costs $1.10 a day and Zesty Paws $1.47.^{2, 7}
• Hip and joint: Zesty Paws. $0.73 a day against $0.96. Zesty Paws prints one 1,510 mg total for its glucosamine, MSM, chondroitin and vitamin E blend. Pet Honesty prints 400 mg of green-lipped mussel and 300 mg of MSM, plus other joint ingredients. At 75 lb Zesty Paws stays at 2 chews ($0.73) and Pet Honesty goes to 3 chews ($1.43).^{3, 8}
• Calming: Zesty Paws. $0.78 a day against $0.96. Zesty Paws prints a 210 mg blend with valerian, L-theanine and L-tryptophan, plus chamomile, passionflower, ginger and ashwagandha. Pet Honesty is the one with melatonin. If you want melatonin, see how much melatonin to give a dog.^{4, 9}

What each label gives a 50 lb dog a day, and the cost a day on Amazon, October 28, 2026.

Source: Zesty Paws and Pet Honesty labels; Amazon prices read October 28, 2026⁵

Cost a day by dog weight

Each label's own dose for that weight at the Amazon price, October 28, 2026.

Both have the NASC Quality Seal

Want a different brand? See the best probiotics for dogs, the best joint supplements, the best calming chews, the best allergy chews. One brand at a time: Is Zesty Paws good? and Is Pet Honesty good?

Questions people ask

Is Zesty Paws better than Pet Honesty?

It depends on the job. Pet Honesty costs less for probiotics ($0.59 vs $0.73 a day for the same 6 billion CFU) and gives more CFU in its allergy chews. Zesty Paws costs less for joints ($0.73 vs $0.96) and calming ($0.78 vs $0.96).

Which has the better probiotic, Zesty Paws or Pet Honesty?

Pet Honesty. Both give a 50 lb dog 6 billion CFU a day. Pet Honesty is $0.59 a day and Zesty Paws is $0.73. Above 50 lb, Pet Honesty gives more CFU because it doses 1 chew per 25 lb.

Pet Honesty vs Zesty Paws allergy chews: which is better?

They cost the same, $0.73 a day for a 50 lb dog. Pet Honesty gives 1 billion CFU and 400 mg turmeric root (Curcuma zedoaria). Zesty Paws gives 200 mg colostrum and 500 million CFU.

Pet Honesty vs Zesty Paws calming: which is better?

Zesty Paws costs less ($0.78 vs $0.96 a day for a 50 lb dog). Pet Honesty is the one with melatonin.

Do Zesty Paws and Pet Honesty have the NASC seal?

Yes. Both are on the National Animal Supplement Council member list with permission to show the Quality Seal.

Which is cheaper, Zesty Paws or Pet Honesty?

For a 50 lb dog, Pet Honesty is cheaper for probiotics, Zesty Paws is cheaper for joints and calming, and allergy chews cost the same. Prices change, so check the cost on Amazon.